fix(studio): remove keyframe dragging from the timeline (#1763)

Dragging timeline keyframe diamonds was unreliable — clip<->tween percentage
remapping, an optimistic-hold workaround, and an intermittent no-op/revert when
the GSAP session lagged the drag (its own comments document the flakiness). Remove
the drag interaction entirely: diamonds still display, click-to-seek, and offer the
context menu (add/remove/ease) — keyframe timing is edited via the playhead + panel,
which are deterministic. Deletes the keyframe-move plan module + its wiring through
TimelineClipDiamonds -> TimelineCanvas -> Timeline -> TimelineEditContext.
This commit is contained in:
Miguel Ángel
2026-06-27 11:33:14 -04:00
committed by GitHub
parent 2d3b19d255
commit cf8f8aa568
8 changed files with 4 additions and 448 deletions
@@ -1,101 +0,0 @@
import { describe, it, expect } from "vitest";
import { pickKeyframeTween, computeKeyframeMovePlan } from "./keyframeMove";
const flat = (id: string, target: string, position: number, duration: number, group?: string) => ({
id,
targetSelector: target,
position,
duration,
resolvedStart: position,
propertyGroup: group,
});
const el = { start: 0, duration: 10, domId: "box", selector: "#box" };
describe("pickKeyframeTween", () => {
it("matches by the element's selector", () => {
const anims = [flat("a", "#other", 0, 5), flat("b", "#box", 2, 3)];
expect(pickKeyframeTween(anims, el, 3, undefined)?.id).toBe("b");
});
it("prefers the dragged keyframe's property group", () => {
const anims = [flat("pos", "#box", 0, 8, "position"), flat("vis", "#box", 0, 8, "visual")];
expect(pickKeyframeTween(anims, el, 1, "visual")?.id).toBe("vis");
});
it("among same-group tweens picks the one whose window contains the original time", () => {
const fadeIn = flat("in", "#box", 1, 1, "visual");
const fadeOut = flat("out", "#box", 8, 1, "visual");
expect(pickKeyframeTween([fadeIn, fadeOut], el, 8.5, "visual")?.id).toBe("out");
expect(pickKeyframeTween([fadeIn, fadeOut], el, 1.2, "visual")?.id).toBe("in");
});
it("returns undefined when there are no tweens", () => {
expect(pickKeyframeTween([], el, 1, undefined)).toBeUndefined();
});
it("returns undefined rather than editing another element on a selector mismatch", () => {
const anims = [flat("a", "#other", 0, 5), flat("b", ".unrelated", 2, 3)];
expect(pickKeyframeTween(anims, el, 3, undefined)).toBeUndefined();
});
});
describe("computeKeyframeMovePlan — flat tween", () => {
const anim = flat("t", "#box", 2, 4); // window [2, 6]
it("start point trims the front, keeping the end fixed", () => {
// newPct 30% → abs 3 → start moves to 3, duration shrinks to 3.
const plan = computeKeyframeMovePlan(anim, 0, el, 30);
expect(plan.meta).toEqual({ position: 3, duration: 3 });
expect(plan.removes).toEqual([]);
});
it("end point resizes, keeping the start", () => {
// tweenOldPct 100 (end) → newPct 80% → abs 8 → duration 6, start unchanged.
const plan = computeKeyframeMovePlan(anim, 100, el, 80);
expect(plan.meta).toEqual({ position: 2, duration: 6 });
});
});
describe("computeKeyframeMovePlan — keyframe-array tween", () => {
const anim = {
id: "k",
targetSelector: "#box",
position: 0,
duration: 10,
resolvedStart: 0,
keyframes: {
keyframes: [
{ percentage: 0, properties: { x: 0 } },
{ percentage: 50, properties: { x: 50 } },
{ percentage: 100, properties: { x: 100 } },
],
},
};
it("moves an intermediate keyframe without touching the tween or others", () => {
// mid keyframe (tweenPct 50) → newPct 70% → abs 7 → 70% of the tween.
const plan = computeKeyframeMovePlan(anim, 50, el, 70);
expect(plan.meta).toBeUndefined();
expect(plan.removes).toEqual([50]);
expect(plan.adds).toEqual([{ pct: 70, properties: { x: 50 } }]);
});
it("start move remaps intermediates to preserve their absolute times", () => {
// start (tweenPct 0) → newPct 20% → abs 2 → window [2,10]. The 50% keyframe
// was at abs 5 → now (5-2)/8 = 37.5%.
const plan = computeKeyframeMovePlan(anim, 0, el, 20);
expect(plan.meta).toEqual({ position: 2, duration: 8 });
expect(plan.removes).toContain(50);
const mid = plan.adds.find((a) => a.properties.x === 50);
expect(mid?.pct).toBeCloseTo(37.5, 1);
});
it("is a no-op when the dragged keyframe can't be located (stale cache)", () => {
// tweenOldPct 33 matches no keyframe (0/50/100) → must NOT resize the tween.
const plan = computeKeyframeMovePlan(anim, 33, el, 70);
expect(plan.meta).toBeUndefined();
expect(plan.removes).toEqual([]);
expect(plan.adds).toEqual([]);
});
});
@@ -1,151 +0,0 @@
/**
* Pure helpers for committing a keyframe-diamond drag: pick the tween the
* dragged keyframe belongs to, and compute the GSAP mutations (tween
* position/duration and/or keyframe add/remove) for the move. Kept free of
* React/store so the timeline drag handler stays a thin orchestrator.
*/
interface TweenLike {
id: string;
targetSelector: string;
position: number | string;
duration?: number;
resolvedStart?: number;
propertyGroup?: string;
keyframes?: { keyframes: { percentage: number; properties: Record<string, number | string> }[] };
}
interface ElementWindow {
start: number;
duration: number;
domId?: string;
selector?: string;
}
export interface KeyframeMovePlan {
/** Tween timing change (start/end point drags). */
meta?: { position: number; duration: number };
/** Keyframe percentages to remove, then re-add (intermediate move / remap). */
removes: number[];
adds: { pct: number; properties: Record<string, number | string> }[];
}
const round3 = (n: number) => Math.round(n * 1000) / 1000;
const clampPct = (n: number) => Math.max(0, Math.min(100, Math.round(n * 100) / 100));
const MIN_DUR = 0.05;
function tweenWindow(a: TweenLike): { start: number; dur: number } {
return {
start: a.resolvedStart ?? (typeof a.position === "number" ? a.position : 0),
dur: a.duration ?? 0,
};
}
type Kf = { percentage: number; properties: Record<string, number | string> };
/**
* Remap every keyframe except `keepIdx` from the old tween window to the new one
* so their absolute times stay fixed after a start/end resize. Returns the
* remove/add ops (empty for flat tweens, which have no intermediates).
*/
function remapKeyframes(
kfs: Kf[],
keepIdx: number,
oldStart: number,
oldDur: number,
newStart: number,
newDur: number,
): Pick<KeyframeMovePlan, "removes" | "adds"> {
const removes: number[] = [];
const adds: KeyframeMovePlan["adds"] = [];
if (newDur <= 0) return { removes, adds };
for (let i = 0; i < kfs.length; i++) {
if (i === keepIdx) continue;
const k = kfs[i]!;
const absT = oldStart + (k.percentage / 100) * oldDur;
const remapped = clampPct(((absT - newStart) / newDur) * 100);
if (Math.abs(remapped - k.percentage) < 0.05) continue;
removes.push(k.percentage);
adds.push({ pct: remapped, properties: k.properties });
}
return { removes, adds };
}
/**
* Pick the tween the dragged keyframe belongs to: restrict to the element's
* selector and (if known) the keyframe's property group, then choose the one
* whose time window contains — or is nearest — the keyframe's original time.
* An element can have several tweens in one group (e.g. fade-in + fade-out).
*/
export function pickKeyframeTween<T extends TweenLike>(
anims: T[],
el: ElementWindow,
origAbsTime: number,
group: string | undefined,
): T | undefined {
const selectors = [el.domId ? `#${el.domId}` : null, el.selector].filter(Boolean);
const forEl = anims.filter((a) => selectors.includes(a.targetSelector));
// Only ever pick among THIS element's tweens. Don't fall back to all
// animations — a selector mismatch (e.g. a class/compound-selector tween)
// would otherwise edit a different element's keyframes. No match → no-op.
if (forEl.length === 0) return undefined;
const groupPool = group ? forEl.filter((a) => a.propertyGroup === group) : [];
const candidates = groupPool.length > 0 ? groupPool : forEl;
const dist = (a: T): number => {
const { start, dur } = tweenWindow(a);
if (origAbsTime >= start && origAbsTime <= start + dur) return 0;
return Math.min(Math.abs(origAbsTime - start), Math.abs(origAbsTime - (start + dur)));
};
return candidates.reduce((best, a) => (dist(a) < dist(best) ? a : best), candidates[0]!);
}
/**
* Compute the mutations for moving a keyframe to `newPct` (clip-relative):
* - start point → trim front (position moves, end fixed),
* - end point → resize (duration changes, start fixed),
* - intermediate → move only that keyframe; start/end moves remap the other
* keyframes so their absolute times stay put.
*/
// fallow-ignore-next-line complexity
export function computeKeyframeMovePlan(
anim: TweenLike,
tweenOldPct: number,
el: ElementWindow,
newPct: number,
): KeyframeMovePlan {
const newAbsTime = el.start + (newPct / 100) * el.duration;
const tweenStart = tweenWindow(anim).start;
const tweenDur = anim.duration ?? el.duration;
const kfs = anim.keyframes
? anim.keyframes.keyframes.slice().sort((a, b) => a.percentage - b.percentage)
: null;
const idx = kfs ? kfs.findIndex((k) => Math.abs(k.percentage - tweenOldPct) < 0.5) : -1;
// Keyframe-array tween but the dragged keyframe couldn't be located (stale
// cache / precision drift): no-op rather than falling through to an end-point
// resize that would silently rescale the whole tween and re-time every key.
if (kfs && idx === -1) return { removes: [], adds: [] };
if (kfs && idx > 0 && idx < kfs.length - 1) {
const movedPct = tweenDur > 0 ? clampPct(((newAbsTime - tweenStart) / tweenDur) * 100) : 0;
return { removes: [tweenOldPct], adds: [{ pct: movedPct, properties: kfs[idx]!.properties }] };
}
const isStartPoint = kfs ? idx === 0 : tweenOldPct <= 50;
let newStart = tweenStart;
let newDur = tweenDur;
if (isStartPoint) {
const end = tweenStart + tweenDur;
newStart = Math.max(0, Math.min(newAbsTime, end - MIN_DUR));
newDur = end - newStart;
} else {
newDur = Math.max(MIN_DUR, newAbsTime - tweenStart);
}
const windowChanged = newStart !== tweenStart || newDur !== tweenDur;
const remap =
kfs && windowChanged
? remapKeyframes(kfs, idx, tweenStart, tweenDur, newStart, newDur)
: { removes: [], adds: [] };
return { meta: { position: round3(newStart), duration: round3(newDur) }, ...remap };
}